Rule 3.9.Advocate in Nonadjudicative Proceedings
A lawyer representing a client before a legislative or
administrative tribunal in a nonadjudicative proceeding shall disclose
that the appearance is in a representative capacity and shall conform to
the provisions of Rules 3.3(a) through (c), 3.4(a) through (c), and 3.5.
|
ANNOTATIONSCOMMENT
[1]In representation before bodies such as legislatures,
municipal councils, and executive and administrative agencies acting in
a rule-making or policy-making capacity, lawyers present facts,
formulate issues and advance argument in the matters under
consideration. The decision-making body, like a court, should be able
to rely on the integrity of the submissions made to it. A lawyer
appearing before such a body should deal with the tribunal honestly and
in conformity with applicable rules of procedure.
In all appearances before legislative bodies, municipal councils,
administrative agencies, and the like, a lawyer should identify himself
or herself and, if the lawyer is appearing in a representative capacity,
indicate that fact. The lawyer should also disclose to the agency the
identity of the client or clients on whose behalf the lawyer is
appearing, unless the identity is privileged.
[2]Lawyers have no exclusive right to appear before
nonadjudicative bodies, as they do before a court. The requirements of
this Rule therefore may subject lawyers to regulations inapplicable to
advocates who are not lawyers. However, legislatures and administrative
agencies have a right to expect lawyers to deal with them as they deal
with courts.
[3]This Rule does not apply to representation of a client
in a negotiation or other bilateral transaction with a governmental agency;
representation in such a transaction is governed by Rules 4.1 through
4.4.
COMMITTEE COMMENT
This Rule takes some of the provisions that were in the Code and
that applied to lawyers appearing before tribunals, such as DR
7-106(B)(1), and extends those provisions to apply equally in front of
administrative or legislative bodies. The Committee approved this Rule
reasoning that most of the provisions in this Rule are already embodied
in EC 7-15, EC 7-16 and EC 7-8 and belong in a Rule. The comments to
the Rule were expanded to include some language from EC 7-15 that help
explain a lawyer's obligations when appearing before administrative or
legislative bodies.
ANNOTATION
Annotator's note.
Rule 3.9 is similar to
DR 7-106 as it
existed prior to the 1992 repeal and reenactment of the Code of
Professional Responsibility.
Relevant cases construing
that provision have
been included in the annotations to Rule 3.3.
|